Oh, I heard it through the grapevine but is it right or all wrong?

The chorus to the old Creedence Clearwater Revival classic written by Marvin Gaye.

"Oh I heard it through the grapevine and I’m just about to lose my mind"

The "grapevine" effect was discussed in a recent Queensland Appeal Court case dealing with defamation of a regional shed builder. The plaintiff, Mr P, sued a Mr R in relation to a number of statements Mr R made to three different people. A jury had found the statements defamatory and Mr P had been awarded damages by the trial Judge. Mr R appealed the decision.

The plaintiff, Mr P was a registered builder who often constructed sheds as a sub-contractor for a shed supplier Mr S and he referred Mr R to Mr P.

Mr R was not happy with the shed and put a number of complaints to Mr P about the shed, including alleged breaks in concrete and cracks in the workshop floor.

Mr R repeated his allegations, which included that Mr P was "an incompetent builder", and a "dishonest builder", to the shed supplier Mr S. Mr S was the source of a lot of work to Mr P. Mr R also made similar statements to Mr P’s apprentice and to another sub-contractor.

The trial judge hearing the case had noted that the impact of what the judge called the "grapevine effect", could be damaging, particularly in a regional area. In fact, Mr S stopped referring work to Mr P, which obviously had an impact on his business.

The trial judge heard evidence that Mr P had a reputation for honesty and was held in high regard, and that his standing was a matter of importance to him. That is not surprising as a reputation is important to all of us.

In William Shakespeare’s play Othello, one of his characters said "reputation, reputation, reputation! O, I have lost my reputation! I have lost the immortal part of myself, and what remains is bestial".

Politicians however can take a different attitude. Margaret Thatcher apparently said "I always cheer up immensely if an attack is particularly wounding because I think, well, if they attack one personally, it means they have not a single political argument left". Talk about a thick hide!

The trial judge awarded $50,000 plus legal costs against the unhappy customer Mr R and that award was confirmed by the Appeal Court.

While a defamatory complaint about someone’s work in a capital city may not cause the person defamed as much real damage, because they operate in a bigger market, there may still be a "grapevine effect", but it may not have as big an impact as in a regional area.

The law of course is now having to deal with defamation in the context of social media. Recommendations or criticisms on social media can have a large impact on businesses.

I am sure many readers, when they are looking to take a holiday, will check out "Trip Advisor" and make a decision on where to stay based, at least in part, on comments from other customers.

That however is a topic for another day.

And for the last words, from Marvin Gaye:

"People say believe half of what you see, Son, and none of what you hear.

I can’t help bein’ confused…

Don’t you know …"

Details: agoode@mellorolsson.com.au or (08) 8414 3400

Practice Area: Court Litigation & Dispute Resolution

Head Office

5th Floor, 80 King William Street Adelaide, South Australia 5000
t: Australia (08) 8414 3400  International +61 8 8414 3400
t: Australia (08) 8414 3400
t: International +61 8 8414 3400
f: Australia (08) 8414 3444  International +61 8 8414 3444
f: Australia (08) 8414 3444
f: International +61 8 8414 3444

Connect With Us

ShareThis

New Look.

Same people.

We're refreshing our look to better represent the service we're providing! Our new website is coming soon.

enter our existing website